Make a New Normal

Our Kids Deserve Better Than Columbus Day

Let’s give Columbus Day the heave-ho. It is long past time.

Besides, it isn’t a big deal anyway.

Columbus Day is the lamest of national holidays:

There are no long-standing American traditions of cookouts and celebrations today.

It has no significant religious connections other than the fact that Chris was Catholic.

It isn’t beloved for its parades, its recognition of loyalty, or fun celebrations of spooks or tricks.

The only thing remarkable about Columbus Day is its ironic reputation for commerce.

Our prices are so low, it’s a steal

It’s almost as if you are destroying our culture! Ha ha!

Tradition doesn’t trump the truth.

Thankfully, The Oatmeal doesn’t just want us to end a bad holiday which possesses no logical, traditional, or rational reason for being a national event. It suggests a more honorable replacement: Bartolomé Day.

As this art piece created for Columbus Day last year argues, Bartolomé de las Casas was, like Columbus, a morally-compromised adventurer. But rather than celebrate a man’s greed and sociopathy, we have the opportunity to celebrate personal transformation.

Because when I consider Bartolomé de las Casas,

both the things he did and the person he was, I think:

now this is a man whom children should learn about in school.

This should be the sole reason for maintaining a tradition. Not our own fear of change, but what we actually want our children to learn. Such as how to be better people.

4 responses

  1. Harold A. Brown Avatar
    Harold A. Brown

    The pactice and adherence of the holidays are nearly all lost to commercialism. The truth and purpose for which these holidays were presented were to remember the sacrifice, the faith and the commitment to truth and honesty has been replaced by lies, greed and conviction to get something for nothing. Our society has exchanged hard work to beg and receive handouts as if it was obligated to them by the prosperity of the rich. You could remove all holidays if this is the teachings you wish to provide to the upcoming generations that will continue making selfish greddy decisions as our politicians are doing today. Christopher Columbus believed the truth of the world being round and acted on the truth and conviction of his faith. We would rather teach that we should do right in our own eyes rather than stand in the gap where the weak have fallen and allow the banner of faith to be disregarded and trampled on by infadels.

    1. Thanks for the comment, Harold!

  2. I’ve heard other places replacing it – or proposing to replace it – with “Indigenous Peoples Day”. I think it’s possible to take political correctness too far. But I also think it’s important to look back at why we do what we do and make revisions when our societal understanding has advanced to the point that someone’s flaws just too far overwhelm their strengths. As far as Harold’s assessment that the holiday was “celebrating truth”, I had thought that the Knights of Columbus pushed it so they’d have a holiday honoring a Catholic man. And even if he did believe the world was round and set out to prove it, what he did to the people who he encountered (in my mind) far outweighs his search for “truth”. I’m all for throwing it out or replacing it too.

    1. Thank you for the comment! You raise a great point about the conflict of character–where is the tipping point when the stuff you don’t want celebrated overtakes the stuff you do.

      I wonder, too if there is a place of too much avoiding the bad stuff. Blind to the bad, reinforce the good.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.